Monday, October 5, 2026

Ahmes going to St. Ives Project Reflection

I found solving the Ahmes going to St. Ives riddle with my classmates in 3 different ways to be a fun exercise.  I was surprised to find that the technique I resonated the least with was the modern one (using the geometric series). I felt much more connected to the numbers themselves using the Egyptian doubling method as well as the counting board. Both of these were less compact, but extremely visual, which made the math feel more tangible to me. I think showing multiple ways of solving the same problem is valuable to students because it increases their depth of understanding by providing different perspectives. In particular, it is important to try to include explanations that are visual in addition to arithmetic solutions.

By kismet, this weekend a friend said to me how doubling numbers is so much easier than any other multiplications. This is a friend of mine who felt very discouraged by high school math. I showed her the Egyptian doubling technique and how using the Egyptian numerals made it that much more intuitive. She was so excited by the method and it was fun for me to share. I hope to instil in my students the idea that math isn't just about solving problems, but that there is joy in the process and in the understanding.

I also found it so funny that as a team we all fell into the trap of "ignoring the dressing" and assuming all three problems were asking the exact same thing. It wasn't until we reread the riddle much later that we noticed our oversight. This experience underscores a commitment I already had to be mindful of this trap with my own students. When it comes to assessment I don't plan to penalize such oversights but instead test for the underlying understanding, while still discussing with the student the benefits of reading instructions closely even when you think you can assume what a problem is asking. (But sometimes this is easier said than done!)

No comments:

Post a Comment

Personality of Numbers: Inherent or Assigned?

I had the following two pauses when reading Numbers with Personality by Alice Major (2017). I want to start with the following quote from pa...